Using Options to Predict Future Closing Prices! The Mid June 2014 Edition.

June 16th, 2014 by 
PK

What happens when you take options prices, treat the current trading price as your 'key', and take the range of differences between the current trading price of various contracts and that new, 'key' price?

Well, in our experience, an interesting series... but not necessarily an accurate prediction of where the market is headed.  In fact - this series has been a disappointment, and over the months where we've actually reviewed "market" predictions, it has lost to a coin-flip in predicting direction and magnitude (note: we actually use a 75% bound, so we should see 75% victories if this series was perfectly accurate).

What Are We Measuring?

Well, first, we like to use the S&P 500 in the form of the ETF SPX - that's our bread and butter, and we even built a reinvestment calculator on the S&P 500.

We've delved into the topic a few more times, almost serendipitously on Seeking Alpha - and one explanation sticks out for why it's not a predictive series: it's an insurance trade.  Sort of like VIX, it's possible, or even likely, that a lot of the traffic in options on the S&P 500 doesn't come from grandmas writing covered calls, but in large institutions protecting their ETFs and Mutual Fund holdings.

With that in mind, we suppose that these numbers are still worthy - except, now, we present them for a more capitalistic reason - if you're clever enough, you can make money selling insurance to this market.  We'll leave that part up to you, but as for the information: here are where the deviations from our S&P 500 'key' price are saying about the future!

How to Read These Charts

Medians should be obvious, and highs and lows are the 75% error band - if this data was predictive (we told you it probably isn't, remember?) future prices would fall into the bands 75% of the time.  Your job is to figure out what to do with the data now that you have it - it is slightly different for calls and puts.

Calls

Puts

 

Calls

Calls

 

And, if you want to see some hard numbers:

06/20/1407/18/1408/15/1409/19/1410/17/1412/19/1401/16/1503/20/1506/19/1512/18/1501/15/1612/16/16
Put High1937.501940.001938.181932.361945.001921.351935.002201.111955.002441.001959.222225.00
Put Medium1925.041900.001897.841865.001890.281842.001683.511830.001875.001889.171790.061841.22
Put Low1880.001830.001819.111710.261740.861720.001353.811712.321408.571512.871659.011659.21
 06/20/1407/18/1408/15/1409/19/1410/17/1412/19/1401/16/1503/20/1506/19/1512/18/1501/15/1612/16/16
Call High1961.881960.001977.761980.001988.041990.371975.002000.002001.192190.961992.582025.00
Call Median1940.001940.001940.761932.051932.431921.821937.811921.431915.001815.061847.911875.00
Call Low1930.001910.001918.011880.001842.561860.241895.001845.001710.001625.001778.241575.00

(Numbers retrieved Saturday, June 14).

Okay, go off and do something with it!

      

PK

PK started DQYDJ in 2009 to research and discuss finance and investing and help answer financial questions. He's expanded DQYDJ to build visualizations, calculators, and interactive tools.

PK lives in New Hampshire with his wife, kids, and dog.

Don't Quit Your Day Job...

DQYDJ may be compensated by our partners if you make purchases through links. See our disclosures page. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Sign Up For Emails
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram